The Cognitive

Rank the shortlist the way your hiring manager would

Turn the hiring manager's three must-haves into grades. For every candidate: a match grade, one line on why, and the one thing to ask on the call. Here are the grading rules, the skill, and a podium to practise on.

Step zero: get the three must-haves right

The ranking is only as good as what you grade against. Ask the hiring manager these, and write their answers in their words.

1. If you could only check three things on a profile, what are they? 2. Put them in order. If two people tie, which one wins? 3. For each one: what would you need to see on a profile to believe it? What wouldn't count? 4. Who on your team today has all three? (Their profile is your answer key.) 5. Who did you meet recently who looked right on paper and wasn't? What was missing?

Then rewrite each must-have as something a person has done, in the past tense: “ran payroll across several states”, not “multi-state payroll knowledge”. If you can't write it as a past action, it can't be checked on a profile. Move it to the interview.

Three levels of evidence

Grade each must-have on its own, for each candidate. Only what's on the profile counts.

2 points

Proven

A line in their work history says they did it themselves, in the last five years, at a size close to this role.

QUOTE LOOKS LIKE“Moved payroll for 1,400 staff onto a new system.”
1 point

Likely

Close but not quite: the team did it (“we”), it was more than five years ago, it was much smaller, or the title and employer strongly suggest it but no line says so.

QUOTE LOOKS LIKE“Part of the team that rolled out a new payroll system.”
0 points

No sign

Nothing in the work history. A skills-list word, a headline claim or an endorsement is still no sign.

QUOTE LOOKS LIKESkills: Payroll Systems · System Implementation
Strong

5 or 6 points, and must-have 1 is Proven.

Good

4 points or more, and must-have 1 is at least Likely.

Maybe

2 points or more. A person with no sign of must-have 1 can never be above Maybe, however strong the rest is.

Not a match

0 or 1 point. Keep them off the list you send.

Ties break by must-have 1, then must-have 2. If they're still tied, say so: the call decides.

Build the podium

Edit the three must-haves if you like. Then tap any evidence button to switch it between Proven, Likely and No sign, and watch the podium reorder. People are made up.

The hiring manager's three, in order
Try this: switch Daniel's must-have 1 to Proven. Then switch Laura's to No sign.
100+ recruiters have shared their feedback
“juicebox, metaview, your looks faster and easier to use but with more relevant profiles”
LinkedIn message: compared with Juicebox and Metaview, faster and easier to use with more relevant profiles

Make Claude do the ranking

Four steps. Step 4 is the one that makes the hiring manager trust the list.

Add the ranking skill

Save this as SKILL.md in a folder called podium-rank, zip the folder, and add it in Claude's settings under Skills. If skills aren't open on your plan, paste the text into a Project's instructions.

--- name: podium-rank description: Ranks candidates against a hiring manager's three must-haves. For each person writes a match grade, one line on why with a quote from their profile, and the one question to ask on the call. Use when I paste must-haves and one or more candidate profiles, or ask to rank or grade a shortlist. --- # Podium rank You rank candidates the way the hiring manager would: against their three must-haves, in their order, using only what the profile shows. ## What I give you - MUST-HAVES: three, in order. Must-have 1 is the one the hiring manager would fight for. - For each must-have, if I have it: what counts as proof, and what doesn't. - CANDIDATES: full profile text for each (headline, every role with dates and description, education, skills). If a must-have is not something a profile could show (a trait, a soft skill), stop and tell me to move it to the interview and give you a different one. ## Grade each must-have, for each candidate PROVEN (2): a line in their work history shows they did it themselves, in the last 5 years, at a size close to this role. You must be able to quote the line. LIKELY (1): close but not quite. The team did it ("we", "part of"), it was more than 5 years ago, it was much smaller, or the title and employer strongly suggest it with no line that says so. NO SIGN (0): nothing in the work history. Skills lists, headlines, endorsements, certificates and "familiar with" never count above NO SIGN on their own. Read dates. A quote from a job that ended more than 5 years ago is LIKELY at best. "I" and "led" are stronger than "we" and "supported". Numbers (people, money, sites, states) set size. ## Overall grade STRONG: 5-6 points and must-have 1 is PROVEN. GOOD: 4+ points and must-have 1 is at least LIKELY. MAYBE: 2+ points. Anyone with NO SIGN on must-have 1 is MAYBE at most. NOT A MATCH: 0-1 point. Rank by grade, then points, then must-have 1, then must-have 2. If still tied, write "tie: the call decides". ## The one line on why - One sentence, under 25 words, starting with the strongest must-have. - It must hold a short quote from the profile, in quotation marks. - Name the gap if there is one: "no sign of [must-have]". - Never: "great fit", "strong background", "impressive", "seems", "passionate", or any praise without a quote. ## The one call question Aim it at the weakest must-have. If two are tied for weakest, aim at the one higher in the order. - LIKELY: ask what they did themselves and how big it was. "When you moved payroll to the new system, what was your part, and how many people were on it?" - NO SIGN: ask whether they have done it, with a way to say no. "Have you ever led a team yourself? If not, what's the closest you've come?" - All three PROVEN: ask about the move, not the skills. "What would make you leave [current employer] for this?" One question. Open, not yes/no unless it gives a way to say no. Specific to this person: use their employer, their project, their numbers. ## Output A table first: rank | name | grade | points | MH1 | MH2 | MH3 Then for each person, in rank order: [rank]. [Name] · [current title], [employer] · [GRADE] Why: [one line with a quote] Ask: [one question] Then: - NOT SENT: the NOT A MATCH people, one line each on what was missing. - WATCH: anyone whose grade rests on a single quote, or whose profile looks out of date (no role ending in the last year, no current role). ## Rules - Never invent a fact, a number or a quote. If you can't quote it, it is NO SIGN. - Never grade on name, photo, age, school prestige, gaps between jobs or anything not in the must-haves. - Never move someone up because they "look senior" or work somewhere famous. - If I give you more than 15 people, rank them all, but write lines and questions for the top 10 only.

Run it on your shortlist

Paste this, then the profiles. Full profile text, not a summary: the skill needs dates and wording to tell Proven from Likely.

Use the podium-rank skill. Role: [title] · [place] MUST-HAVES, in the hiring manager's order: 1. [past action] · counts: [what proof looks like] · doesn't count: [what doesn't] 2. [past action] · counts: [...] · doesn't count: [...] 3. [past action] · counts: [...] · doesn't count: [...] CANDIDATES: --- [Name 1] [full profile text] --- [Name 2] [full profile text]

Check the output in two minutes

What a good entry looks like. Read the quote before the grade: if the quote doesn't prove the must-have, the grade is wrong.

1. Laura Bennett (L.B.)Strongmade up

Why: Ran payroll across three states, “1,400 staff in TX, OK and LA”, and led the move to a new system; “supervised payroll” but no team size.

Ask: “At Hartwell, how many people were on your payroll team, and who reported to you?”

  • Every “why” has a quote. No quote, send it back.
  • The question targets the weakest must-have, and uses their employer or numbers.
  • Nobody with no sign of must-have 1 is above Maybe.
  • Skim the Not sent list. If someone good is there, a must-have is written too narrowly. Fix the wording, not the grade.

Calibrate with the hiring manager once

Before the first real list, take five people the hiring manager already judged (hired, interviewed, rejected). Run the skill on them and compare. If the grades disagree, the must-haves are wrong, not the hiring manager.

Here are 5 people the hiring manager already judged, with their verdict: [Name] · hired / interviewed / rejected · [their one-line reason] Rank them with the podium-rank skill. Then compare your grades with their verdicts. For every disagreement, tell me which must-have wording caused it and suggest a better wording.

Keep the fixed wording in the skill run for that role. Send the hiring manager the ranked list with the why and the ask showing. They'll argue with a line instead of asking why someone is there.

100+ recruiters have shared their feedback
“pretty good … especially for semiconductor, because it's much harder to find semiconductor talent”
Chat: search quality pretty good, especially for semiconductor talent

The wall

Claude can think, but it can't see people. Plain Claude has no profiles, so it can only rank the people you paste in, one full profile at a time.

It ranks the list you already have. It can't tell you who you missed, the person with all three must-haves and a different title, because it never searched. And a profile pasted last month may already be out of date.

The same podium, two ways

Plain Claude

  1. Get the three must-haves and rewrite them as past actions.
  2. Search, then open each profile and copy the full text.
  3. Paste every profile into Claude with the skill.
  4. Check each quote against the profile.
  5. Calibrate the wording with the hiring manager.
  6. Copy the ranked list into a document for the hiring manager.

Same job in The Cognitive

  1. Describe who you want in a sentence or two, with the three must-haves in it.
  2. People come back ranked by fit, including people with other titles. Every card says why they fit, with a quote from their profile.
  3. Shortlist the ones you want and export the list as a CSV for free.
  4. Want your own grades and call questions on top? Add The Cognitive to Claude as a custom connector with https://app.thecognitive.io/mcp, sign in on the Connect page and allow it. Claude runs the search and applies this skill to what comes back.
100+ recruiters have shared their feedback
“My front runner is … The Cognitive … Yours really beat JuiceBox, PIN, and Metaview”
LinkedIn message: my front runner is The Cognitive.ai; it really beat JuiceBox, PIN, Metaview and Fabric

Hand your hiring manager a ranked list

Make a free account and put the three must-haves in your search. Every person comes back ranked, with the reason and a quote from their profile, so nobody has to ask why someone is on the list.

7-day free trial, 50 sourcing credits, no card.